top of page
Search

What Must Remain Possible?

3 hours ago
7 min read

 


"The hardest part of moving forward may be deciding what we cannot afford to lose."

 

In my work with smallholder mango farmers, I have seen fruit-fly damage fall dramatically when their orchards received effective protection, yet success in one season did not guarantee that their orchards would be protected the next. Sometimes the work depended on project funding that farmers could not afford to replace, a problem an affordable, dependable service could address. But even if such a service were established, what would happen if one of the organizations supporting it changed direction or stopped doing its part?

The question extends far beyond farming. Over time, a company accumulates knowledge and experience, develops specialized equipment, and builds relationships with the people and suppliers who make its products possible. As long as those products continue to reach customers, it is easy to assume that the ability to produce them remains secure, even when some of the activities supporting production have changed or disappeared. The difficulty may become apparent only later, when someone tries to restore an activity the company no longer performs.


Consider Polaroid, the company famous for instant photography. As digital cameras became increasingly popular, Polaroid expected demand for its traditional film to decline. In 2004, it decided to stop manufacturing negatives, the light-sensitive material essential to its instant film, believing its accumulated supply would last another ten years. The company continued making film using those materials, but demand remained stronger than expected, and by 2008 the supplies were nearly exhausted. Polaroid then closed its remaining instant-film factory as it moved away from traditional photography. Yet customers still wanted its products, much of the machinery remained, and experienced employees were available who knew how to make the film. With the machines and expertise still in place, what could prevent production from starting again?

 

What Survived


Florian Kaps, an entrepreneur who believed instant photography still had a future, and André Bosman, the former engineering manager at Polaroid's Enschede factory, decided to find out. They acquired much of the remaining production equipment, rented part of the factory, and brought back experienced former employees. Their new venture, the Impossible Project, set out to manufacture film for existing Polaroid cameras. Yet restarting production proved far more difficult than reuniting the people and machinery.


The difficulty extended beyond the factory itself. Polaroid's instant film relied on a specific combination of chemicals and materials, some of which its original suppliers no longer manufactured. These materials could not simply be replaced with similar ones, because altering one could affect how the others worked together and require changes to the manufacturing process. The former employees knew how to produce film with the original materials, but their experience could not bring back ingredients that were no longer available. To manufacture film again, the Impossible Project had to develop suitable alternatives, establish new supplier relationships, and adapt its production processes.


In March 2010, the Impossible Project introduced new black-and-white instant film compatible with existing Polaroid cameras. The film was not identical to Polaroid's original product, and producing it required a modified manufacturing process that drew on the equipment and expertise the team had recovered. What survived was not enough to reproduce the old film, yet it helped the team find another way to make it.

 

The Difficult Choice


Nearly three decades after I began developing environmentally friendly methods for controlling fruit flies, my team and I reached a point where we believed our technologies and application protocols were ready for much broader commercial use. We had developed solutions for several of the world's most damaging fruit-fly pests, along with methods for developing additional solutions for different applications. Along the way, we had accumulated specialized knowledge, built laboratories and supporting infrastructure, and developed a close-knit team whose members enjoyed their work and had learned to solve difficult problems together. Years of working side by side had given us a shared understanding that went beyond what could be captured in formulas and procedures. Biofeed had not only developed technologies to control fruit flies; we had also developed the collective ability to create new solutions when the next challenge arose.


We now needed to bring those technologies to farmers on a much larger scale. That meant expanding our business development, marketing, and sales activities, bringing in people with expertise different from that of our research team to help build the necessary commercial relationships. Yet the researchers, laboratories, and infrastructure that had made our technological achievements possible still required substantial resources, and Biofeed could not afford to maintain the entire R&D operation while making the investments needed for commercial expansion. Keeping everything in place could leave us without enough resources to reach more farmers, while reducing the research operation could free those resources at the cost of weakening our ability to develop new solutions when we needed them again. How could we find the resources to reach more farmers without losing the ability to develop new technologies in the future?


Keeping our formulas and development protocols seemed essential, but would that be enough? They preserved valuable knowledge about the products we had developed and the methods we used to develop them. Yet if we needed to control another pest or adapt our technology to unfamiliar conditions, the written instructions could not anticipate every difficulty. We would still need people capable of deciding what to test, recognizing why something failed, and finding a way forward when established methods were insufficient. Retaining documents and some equipment could preserve much of what we had learned, but not necessarily our ability to develop something new.


We did not necessarily need our entire R&D operation to run at its previous scale while expanding our commercial activities, but I was certain that further technological development would be necessary. I could not know when we would need it, which pests or applications would demand attention, or whether the people and relationships we relied on would still be available. Reducing the research operation could save resources now, but rebuilding it years later might require assembling people, expertise, and infrastructure at costs we could not foresee, with no guarantee that everything we might give up could later be recovered. The question I faced was therefore more difficult than deciding what to keep and what to give up: What would we need to preserve today to make further development possible when the need arose?

 

Building Forward


Even if Biofeed could eventually rebuild a research team, that would not guarantee we could do so when a new technological challenge demanded an answer. Some expertise might still be available, but assembling the right people, equipment, and working relationships could take time we did not have. The possibility of restarting an activity therefore offered something different from the ability to rely on it. When deciding what to preserve, I had to consider not only whether our research ability could be recovered, but also whether it could return soon enough to meet a future need.


An organization does not always need to keep every activity within its own operations. It may rely on other organizations for specialized knowledge, equipment, or services, freeing resources for other purposes. But having those capabilities elsewhere does not guarantee we can depend on them. The people or organizations providing them must be willing and able to do the work when needed, and the arrangements must remain affordable. Otherwise, we may have exchanged the cost of maintaining an activity ourselves for the uncertainty of depending on someone else. The activity might have moved beyond our organization, but the consequences of its interruption would still be ours to face.


For the mango farmers whose experience began our investigation, knowing that an effective technology existed would not protect their fruit if the service became unavailable when they needed it. A supplier might shift priorities, or a local service provider might stop operating, leaving farmers without protection even though the technology itself remained effective. Another organization might eventually restore the service, but if fruit had already been damaged, that season's lost opportunity could not be recovered. Such interruptions could also make it harder for farmers to plan production, meet buyers' expectations, and invest in their orchards with confidence. An improvement that works exceptionally well in one season becomes a more dependable foundation for prosperity when the arrangements supporting it continue to deliver its benefits, even as the organizations involved change.


This distinction adds an important dimension to our understanding of Retention within the Universal Law of Increasing Complexity (ULIC). Preserving an achievement does not necessarily preserve its usefulness, because the ability it once supported may no longer be available when needed. What matters is whether that ability can continue functioning, remain accessible through other organizations, or be recovered in time as circumstances change. The same understanding strengthens the Prosperity Formula. Social and External Integration connect people to the specialized abilities on which their livelihoods depend, but those relationships must remain dependable as organizations change. Internal Disintegration can weaken them from within, although organizational change itself is not necessarily destructive. Continued development does not require preserving every activity or organization unchanged. What must survive is not necessarily the organization that achieved something, but a dependable way to use what it achieved and build on it when the future demands more.

 

=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=


Until next time,

Nimrod

Dr. Nimrod Israely is an agronomist, entrepreneur, and author exploring the structural foundations of prosperity and organizational development. He is the founder and CEO of Biofeed and Dream Valley. LinkedIn


P.S. Does your organization have capable people, sufficient resources, and the necessary technology, yet still struggle to move forward? The difficulty may lie in the relationship between its Direction and Structure. I help leadership teams identify that gap and determine what needs to change. If this sounds familiar, contact me for an introductory conversation.


Previous column: The Boundaries of Success

 

Was this column useful? I would appreciate your feedback.


I strive to remain faithful to the facts and what they reveal. If you find an error, question an interpretation, or believe something needs clarification, I welcome your insights.


 

 
 
 

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post

+972 54-252-3425

©2022 by DreamValleyGlobal. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page