top of page
Search

The Boundaries of Success

Nov 13
7 min read

Updated: Nov 14

 


"Our past does not dictate our future; it makes some futures more probable."

 

Extreme cases are essential to how I investigate complex systems because they reveal relationships that are difficult to recognize under less extreme conditions. One revealing example comes from my work with smallholder farmers, where I have seen agricultural technologies increase harvests and incomes by tens or even hundreds of percent, yet families remain far from lasting prosperity. This contradiction between substantial improvements and persistent poverty led me to develop the Prosperity Formula, which examines how social integration, external integration, and internal disintegration influence prosperity. It also prompted a broader investigation that led me to the Universal Law of Increasing Complexity (ULIC), a proposed general theory of how systems emerge, develop, and fall apart.


Discovering a relationship under extreme conditions does not establish how broadly it applies. Smallholder poverty is a major global challenge in its own right, yet the questions it raises about development are also worth asking of organizations that have already achieved prosperity. This column therefore turns to successful companies and communities to investigate how the strengths inherited from past achievements both open new opportunities and constrain the futures they are able to pursue.

 

The Inheritance


In 2007, Fujifilm, one of the world's leading producers of photographic film, introduced ASTALIFT, a line of skincare products. Demand for film was falling sharply as digital photography spread, while the company was entering a market far removed from the one that had established its reputation. The decision raises a fundamental question: what had Fujifilm gained from decades of success that could help it pursue such a different future, and what would it need to develop anew?


Founded in Japan in 1934, Fujifilm spent decades developing expertise in the chemistry and precision manufacturing of photographic film. That success left three interconnected inheritances: Capabilities developed through its technological and organizational experience; Relationships among its people and with suppliers, customers, and other partners; and an Organizational Memory shaped by accumulated experience, established practices, and a shared understanding of the company's role. Together, these inheritances provided foundations for new opportunities, but they did not by themselves answer what kind of company Fujifilm could become.


A Harvard Business School case records Fujifilm's CEO asking, "If we aren't an imaging company, then what are we?" Many of us answer questions about our identity by naming our occupation, because years of work shape both our skills and our self-understanding. Organizations can develop a similar attachment to the activities that made them successful, narrowing the opportunities they see as compatible with who they are. For Fujifilm, the question was whether a history built around imaging had to define its future, even if its accumulated strengths could support very different activities.

 

Different Futures


Under its VISION75 strategy, launched in 2004, Fujifilm examined how the expertise accumulated through photographic-film production could serve other industries. Producing film had given the company knowledge of collagen, a protein also found in human skin, and antioxidant technologies developed to prevent photographs from fading, both of which contributed to its skincare products. Precision coating technologies also found applications in electronic displays, demonstrating that declining demand for photographic film did not necessarily diminish the value of the Capabilities developed through producing it.


Identifying new applications for its technologies did not automatically enable Fujifilm to build successful businesses around them. The company already had experience beyond photography through Fuji Xerox, established as a joint venture in 1962, and through its activities in healthcare. Nevertheless, entering additional markets required new products, commercial Relationships, and ways to coordinate investment and operations, which Fujifilm developed through research, acquisitions, and organizational change.


Established companies often judge new investments by the returns and risks they have come to expect in familiar markets. Those standards help them allocate resources to businesses they understand, but they can make unfamiliar opportunities less attractive when demand is uncertain and profits may take time to materialize. Managers may therefore recognize the potential of a new direction yet hesitate to invest in the Capabilities and Relationships needed to pursue it, even when those investments could prove important as established markets change.


Kodak, Fujifilm's longtime competitor in photographic film, also invested heavily in digital photography and developed a healthcare business, which it sold in 2007. It led the United States market in digital-camera unit sales in 2004 and 2005, yet those achievements did not generate enough profit to offset earnings lost as photographic film declined. While Fujifilm increasingly sought new applications for the chemistry and precision technologies developed for photographic film, Kodak emphasized helping customers capture, share, and print images. Their contrasting experiences show that developing technologies, winning customers, and even leading an emerging market are different from building profitable businesses that can sustain prosperity as established markets change.

 

Beyond Origins


In steam engines, flywheels helped machinery operate smoothly by storing energy as they rotated. Imagine a flywheel asking itself, "If I am no longer part of a steam engine, then what am I?" Defining it solely by its place in that machine would overlook its more general Capability: storing rotational energy that can serve different purposes. Flywheels have also served internal-combustion engines and, with new designs and supporting systems, modern electrical energy-storage applications. The physical principle remained the same, but each new application required a different way to integrate that Capability into a working system.

An organization may be able to enter an unfamiliar field because some of its most transferable Capabilities lie in how it organizes work, rather than in the specific technologies it uses. I witnessed this at Kibbutz Tzuba, where I grew up. Although agriculture provided most of our livelihood, its operations were already organized much like advanced industrial enterprises, combining specialized activities, professional management, financial planning, and coordinated multidisciplinary teams. Their efficiency and profitability helped sustain a relatively high standard of living. When members began exploring additional sources of income, they believed the community already possessed the organizational Capabilities required to undertake another complex enterprise, even though it would need to acquire the industry's specialized technological expertise. Their search eventually led to automotive windshield manufacturing.


I remember being invited, along with other children, to the Kibbutz members' assembly, where the decision to establish a new industry was approved. The occasion underscored the decision's importance to the entire community. From conversations with members involved in the preceding search, I learned that they weighed commercial prospects and financing alongside questions about hiring people from outside the Kibbutz and providing suitable work for older members. The team that established Oran drew on experience in poultry and dairy farming, orchards, cotton fields, accounting, and management. Although the team lacked specialized expertise in glass manufacturing, its members already knew how to integrate different professions and manage complex collective efforts. For us, the question "If we are not only farmers, then what are we?" had a clear answer: we were a Kibbutz, a community committed to equality and shared responsibility, whose identity and purposes extended beyond any particular economic activity.


Established in Tzuba in 1978, Oran Safety Glass (OSG) grew from automotive windshield manufacturing into an international producer of specialized glazing, with facilities in Israel, the United States, and Spain. Meanwhile, Tzuba's economy diversified beyond its original reliance on agriculture, drawing increasingly on industry, tourism, and income earned by members working outside the Kibbutz. Agriculture continues alongside these activities, and Tzuba remains a relatively prosperous community whose economic foundation is considerably broader than the one on which it depended during my childhood.


Tzuba's move beyond agriculture was part of a broader transformation: by 1980, most Israeli Kibbutzim had established at least one industrial enterprise, though their commercial outcomes varied. Ayelet HaShahar, the Kibbutz where my father was born and where I still have family, established a tire-mold factory in the early 1970s, but the venture eventually failed. Its experience illustrates that the organizational Capability to enter an unfamiliar industry does not guarantee commercial success. Fujifilm applied technological expertise developed through photography to new markets, while Tzuba relied on organizational strengths developed through its industrially managed agriculture to acquire unfamiliar expertise. Both drew on Capabilities, Relationships, and Organizational Memory accumulated through earlier achievements, but sustaining the businesses they built still required effective management as markets and competitive conditions changed.

 

Changing Boundaries


For thousands of years, farming families and village communities sustained agricultural livelihoods and community life through organizational forms that proved remarkably enduring. Like Fujifilm, they accumulated Capabilities, Relationships, and Organizational Memory, though their inheritances took different forms: knowledge of land and crops, ties among households, and practices passed from one generation to the next. Their historical success did not guarantee prosperity or security for everyone, nor did these communities remain unchanged. Yet as markets, technologies, and aspirations evolved, the organizational arrangements that had supported agricultural life did not necessarily provide the specialized expertise, investment capacity, coordination, and external connections needed to pursue new economic opportunities.


When Fujifilm's CEO asked, "If we aren't an imaging company, then what are we?", he posed a question many traditional farming communities might also ask: "If we are not only farmers, then what are we?" At Tzuba, the answer came from an integrated community whose identity and organizational Capabilities already extended beyond agriculture. In many smallholder villages, however, individual farming families may possess considerable expertise and pursue activities beyond agriculture, while the community itself lacks comparable mechanisms for collective investment, specialized management, and coordinated economic development. Their shared history and Relationships can sustain community life without necessarily providing the organizational Capabilities needed to pursue economic opportunities collectively. Hundreds of skilled farming families do not automatically constitute an integrated economic organization, even when they recognize the possibilities such an organization could make attainable.


Alongside this organizational limitation lies an economic one: even substantial increases in production and income may leave families on very small farms far from prosperity, especially when access to profitable markets is limited. Responding to these constraints may require organizational Capabilities and Relationships that open opportunities beyond what individual farms can pursue alone. For some communities, those opportunities may emerge through stronger agricultural value chains; for others, through new industries or sources of livelihood, without abandoning inherited strengths and identities that remain valuable. Prosperous companies face a comparable challenge when established markets change, although their organizational and economic circumstances may be very different. The inheritance of success makes some opportunities easier to recognize and pursue and places others beyond an organization's present reach, but those boundaries can shift as it acquires unfamiliar knowledge and learns to organize it effectively. The lasting advantage is not simply being good at what brought us here, but becoming capable of what a different future requires.

 

=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=-=

 

Until next time,

Nimrod

Dr. Nimrod Israely is an agronomist, entrepreneur, and author exploring the structural foundations of prosperity and organizational development. He is the founder and CEO of Biofeed and Dream Valley. LinkedIn


P.S. Does your organization have capable people, sufficient resources, and the necessary technology, yet still struggle to move forward? The difficulty may lie in the relationship between its Direction and Structure. I help leadership teams identify that gap and determine what needs to change. If this sounds familiar, contact me for an introductory conversation.


 

Was this column useful? I would appreciate your feedback.


I strive to remain faithful to the facts and what they reveal. If you find an error, question an interpretation, or believe something needs clarification, I welcome your insights.


 
 
 

Comments


Post: Blog2_Post

+972 54-252-3425

©2022 by DreamValleyGlobal. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page